Photo: The old Monroe County Courthouse in Monroeville, Ala., completed in 1903, is a centerpiece in the hometown of "To Kill a Mockingbird" author Harper Lee. Photo: Sharon Steinmann/AP
Questions about the origin of Lee’s new novel, “Go Set a Watchman” follow this same pattern: another silver lining bringing its own little cloud. While the literary world thrilled to the discovery of a new Harper Lee book, some Monroeville residents wondered if the 89-year-old Lee was mentally capable of giving the go-ahead to an old manuscript. The state investigated charges of elder abuse, related to the publication of the book, and found no evidence to support them.
Was Lee pressured to publish the book? Hogwash, said novelist Mark Childress, author of “Crazy in Alabama.” Childress, the first Monroeville native to win the Harper Lee Award, said Lee’s publisher wouldn’t release a book of which she didn’t approve. He also suggested that Carter is only doing what her client wants her to do.
One could find out by asking Carter or Harper Lee, but Carter is elusive and Lee has avoided giving interviews since 1965. Her statements on “Watchman” have been issued through Carter. Like the reclusive Boo Radley, whose absence sparked wild rumors in “To Kill a Mockingbird,” Lee’s intangibility offers room for conspiracy theories to grow.
But others in Monroeville take these theories with a grain of salt. George Thomas Jones, 92, long-time columnist for the Monroe Journal, said his first encounter with Nelle Lee was in grade school, when she punched out an older boy in the fifth grade who pulled her hair.
Jones can quote local history back 100 years and cite individuals who inspired many of the characters and events in “Mockingbird,” set in “Maycomb,” the fictional stand-in for Monroeville, even down to the geography. For residents such as Jones, Lee is part of the town’s fabric. Like the mockingbird, she is contentious and territorial, but also makes beautiful music.
Said Dennis Owens, “it used to be you would see her out at a restaurant here or there, and everybody just kept their distance.”
And those who see her more often, like Mary Tucker, the mother of Monroeville’s other Pulitzer Prize winner, former AJC columnist Cynthia Tucker, try an even more effective tactic.
Said Ms. Tucker, “I’ve never talked to her about her book. We talk about other books.”
Please confirm the information below before signing in.